#LetsDiscuss2020 #16 – Reading vs. Watching – #DiscussionSunday.

#LetsDiscuss2020

It is no secret that there are genres I simply will not read, as well as genres that I’ve read and enjoyed, but I don’t often find myself actively searching out to find books in those genres. However, there are genres I’ll watch on TV or as a film that I might never read in a book. So I was wondering…

Are there genres you’ll willingly watch on TV or in movies that you don’t look for to read in a book (and vise versa)? Also, are there genres that are off the table altogether – for reading or watching?

Discussion Sunday #letsdiscuss2020

Disclaimer:

These are my personal opinions. I do not expect anyone to agree with anything here, and in fact, I’m certain that many will disagree and/or even hate many of the things I’ve written below. Sorry about that, but you are always welcome to express your own opinions – be they contrary or comparable – in the comments section. So, with that out of the way…

No Thanks!

There are few genres that I totally and absolutely refuse to read or watch. One of them is Erotica, which to me is just gratuitous sex, which for me is like porn. Look, I get that some people like the softer kind or whatever. Fine; more power to you. Me? No thanks. I’m putting any steamy Romance in with these books and films, because… they feel so fake and… blech! Rippling muscles and swooning women are NOT for me, at all. Frankly, these all seem very misogynistic to me, and some of them border on being sexual and/or psychological abuse (yes, I’m talking to you, 50 Shades).

I think I’ll also put Fantasy in this category. Sure, as a kid I read some fantasy books, and saw some fantasy films – like The Wizard of Oz, for example. But after getting past about 4-6th grade, neither these genres of books nor their film versions have really interested me. For example, I tried and tried and tried to read the Lord of the Rings books, but failed miserably. When the movies came out, I watched the first one with my son, and wasn’t all that impressed (except with the special effects). He tried to get me to watch the second one, and I fell asleep in the middle. I’d put anything Magical in this category as well, although I might forgive a seemingly unrealistic event once in a while in a book, but only as long as the unrealistic parts aren’t the main part of the story.

Another genre that doesn’t interest me in print or on the screen would be Thrillers or what might be called Action movies and TV shows. You know the kind where someone goes off to save the world and gets into all kinds of trouble, and almost gets killed themselves, or almost kills the people they’re supposed to save? Not for me. My one exception to this rule has been James Bond films, and even those are starting to wear thin. In fact, I didn’t bother with the last two Daniel Craig movies. (That said, if they get a POC or a woman for the next Bond, I might move this to the next category.)

I’d put all of those Comic Book and Graphic Novel stories (along with their sub-genres) into this same category. Yes, I did watch a couple of the first Superman movies, one Batman movie, and one Iron Man movie, I have never read any of those, ever, and it seems to me that the special effects overshadow all the stories. By the way, the first Wonder Woman movie with the Israeli actress Gal Gadot was on TV here not long ago. We caught it by accident near the beginning. Well, for heavens sake, did they really HAVE to make almost all the actors put on a semi-Israeli accent because our Gal couldn’t overcome hers? After we noticed that, we switched the channel. My exception to this rule – old Disney classic animated films like Lady and the Tramp, and some of the earlier Pixar films, but these were mostly back when my kids were small enough to appreciate them. Today… meh (which might change if I ever have grandchildren).

I should also mention that I don’t (or rather, almost never) read, Children‘s, YA, Middle Grade or New Adult books. I also don’t care for TV shows that target these age groups either, and will hardly ever watch films aimed at them.

Won’t Read; Might Watch

This is where I put the genres of Paranormal and Horror. By this I mean ghosts, zombies, vampires, and that sort of thing. For example, I did watch Charmed (the original series) and the first couple of seasons of Buffy the Vampire Slayer back in the day, but those had some romance and humor, that today’s shows seem to lack. Mind you, I was an avid viewer of the original TV day-time soap opera Dark Shadows, and I had a HUGE crush on Jonathan Frid, but I was young – forgive me! However, while I can take a ghost as a small element in a book once in a while, if one of these apparitions are the main characters, I certainly won’t want to read that book.

Another genre here is Science Fiction. Again, I have to say that I’ve read some Sci-Fi in my day – classic stuff like Ray Bradbury and the like, but again, these books just don’t float my boat these days. Despite this, I was a Trekkie as a kid and watched a few of the spin-offs (but not faithfully). I saw the first three Star Wars films (which are now called episodes 4-6), but never bothered to see any of the others, not even when they came on TV.

I should add that I love watching Doctor Who, although we took a break after Matt Smith, but we’re back now watching Jodie. For those not in the know, this show is a combination between Science Fiction with some Alternative History into the mix. Similar to this, are things like “The Man in the High Castle” by Philip K. Dick, and “The Plot Against America” by Philip Roth. We watched both of the TV series based on those books, and enjoyed them (for the most part). Although I bought the Roth book, I’m not too keen on reading it. I also don’t like the idea of Alternative Reality books either. One example of this is the newly released book “Rodham” by Curtis Sittenfeld which imagines Hillary Rodham’s life if she had never married Bill Clinton. Um, no thanks to that, and no thanks to that book that imagines Anne Frank’s life if she had survived the Holocaust (which personally, I think is disrespectful of her memory).

There is one category that doesn’t seem to have all that much of a genre in books (that I know of), but which we love to watch. That is Medical dramas. I don’t think I’ve ever read any medical fiction books (or seen many, to be honest), but they sure make for great watching!

Might Read; Will Watch

The number one genre here would be Crime and Legal. Yeah, we love our Criminal Minds, our Law & Order, our Mindhunter, our Good Fight, our Suits, our Bull, and on and on. We also love British crime dramas like Broadchurch, Luther, Happy Valley, and the like. But to be honest, unless it is like, Agatha Christie type crime fiction, which is really Murder Mystery fiction, I’ll probably not want to read it. The thing is, I’m trying to read more of these types of mystery books because well… they can be fun. My biggest problem is that if I can figure out “who done it” too early in a book, you’ve lost me. On the other hand, I often can figure out the perpetrator of many of the TV series in this genre, but I don’t mind that too much (although I prefer to be surprised).

Another one for this category would be Romantic Comedies and Romantic Dramas – what might be considered “chic-lit” or even women’s fiction. Now I like women’s fiction a great deal, both historical and contemporary, but I don’t care for too much romance. If the whole point of the book is for the girl/guy to get the girl/guy, well, I’m not going to want to break the spine of that book. However, I can’t resist a good Rom-Com or Rom-Dram movie. Mind you, I’m less keen on long running TV series of this genre because I just don’t think they’re sustainable for several years. Even “How I Met Your Mother” got tedious after a few seasons. Come to think of it, I’ve noticed I don’t read a whole lot of Comedy/Humor books, but a good sit-com can be a joy to behold!

Yes, Please!

Obviously, Historical Fiction is right up there in this category, and I’ll read and watch practically anything historical (except if they include any of the above noted genres I’ve already nixed). I particularly enjoy those that are Biographical fiction stories and will watch biographical dramatizations as well. Also, good Women’s Fiction, both contemporary and historical, are draws for both print and screen.

I’m sure I’ve missed some genres, but this is already a long post so I’ll stop here!

So… what about you?

Are there genres that do you not read, but will watch on TV or in a movie? Are there genres you will not watch on TV or in a movie that you read in books? Are there genres that are not for you in any format?

This post is my 16th entry in the 2020 Discussion Challenge, hosted by Nicole @ Feed Your Fiction Addiction and Shannon @ It Starts at Midnight!

2020-Discussion-Challenge

 

27 thoughts on “#LetsDiscuss2020 #16 – Reading vs. Watching – #DiscussionSunday.

  1. There are actually lots of genres that I’d watch but wouldn’t read. First off, I’m the opposite of you and almost exclusively read MG and YA, so any adult genres I watch are different than what I read. I’m not at all interested in reading thrillers, for example, but I don’t mind watching them. Great topic!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Very interesting questions. I certainly agree with you about horror – it is so great to see it on screen sometimes, but reading horror often feels underwhelming for me – there are some classic horror books, of course, but nothing scares us as much as something happening on screen (that is simply my opinion). The same happens to me with romantic comedies – It is unlikely I will pick it up in a book form, but I will watch it if a film is very well done – for example, I cannot imagine reading Nora Ephron’s Sleepless in Seattle or You’ve Got Mail – but I adore these very light romantic films.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I think my taste in reading and watching broadly match. Only exception I can think of is romantic comedies. I’ve watched a few of those, but wouldn’t normally read this genre.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I’m pretty much on par with you. I did watch the TV series of Beauty and the Beast and liked it very much. I loved Buffy, but as you say, the humor and brilliant writing made it special. Also, it was well cast. I’d call my reading tastes eclectic – a bit of science fiction by my friend Robert Sawyer, anything by Jane Davis, and then whatever piques my interest via a recommendation, the title, cover, blurb and sample. Right now I’m reading “Five Wives” recommended by a lady in the park. We were both walking our dogs. They decided to say hello so we did too. She had a book in her hand. I asked her about it and that led to a wonderful discussion about books.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I would watch a very occasional superhero film but can’t imagine ever reading a comic. On the whole, I don’t watch much these days but I used to love “cosy” crime like Midsomer Murders which has the same feel as the vintage crime novels I love even though it’s set in the current day. I find contemporary crime far too violent and foul-mouthed to watch mostly – I made it through ten minutes of Killing Eve, for example, before switching off in disgust, but I can read fairly gritty crime novels. And erotica? No thanks – there’s nothing less erotic to my mind than reading about or watching other people having sex!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. I rarely read Sci-Fi, and almost never choose to do so, but my favourite shows include the various Star Trek franchises, Eureka, warehouse 13, Firefly and Quantum Leap. I used to read a lot of horror, but I’ve never been able to watch horror movies.I do love reading and watching crime and mystery though.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Wow! That’s a lotta rules. 😀 I like to read a huge variety of genres. Romance, erotica, mysteries, crime, fantasy, YA, some science fiction (if it isn’t all action), dystopian stuff, “literary fiction,” and the odd biography or autobiography. Occasionally I enjoy nonfic, if it’s about animals or psychological. I don’t usually want to read a book about mob drama, though I love watching it. I want to HEAR them… the way “dose guys” talk makes it fun for me. I don’t like watching erotica because it seems so fake on the screen, would much rather see it in my mind while reading. I probably wouldn’t watch a YA type of movie either. Things I watch but don’t read? Comedy… delivery is important! And musicals 🎶💖

    Liked by 1 person

  8. I’m sure other people do this, too, but I don’t think I’ve ever seen anyone else mention there are genres they prefer watching to reading! For me, it’s fluffy romance chick lit stuff. I guess I don’t have anything against it in books, and I do read them occasionally, but for some reason I find it more enjoyable as a film.

    I don’t like horror/thrillers in general, but I do think it works better as film, too. I find it scarier.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. I’m actually pretty consistent between what I read and what I watch. I’m not much into romance or drama stories that make me cry – which is meaningful ones about pets or ones where a parent or child dies. I just can’t handle them. But I like most other things. I have a wide-variety of likes.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. I think it’s helpful for a satisfying reading life to know which genres are appealing and which are not! I avoid many of the same genres you do! I will not read horror or paranormal or erotica … and I avoid violence (domestic abuse, child abuse, animal cruelty, child abduction, serial killers, true crime, etc). Some of the histfic content can be troublesome. I do like an occasional well written middle grade and young adult! In fact, last night I just enjoyed Bloomability by Creech! I find them to be refreshing palate cleansers! Oh…I usually avoid chick lit and have learned to avoid authors like Hillenbrand. I have found an occasional chick lit with more substantial content though. Great discussion post Davida!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.