TCL’s Top Ten Tuesday for January 14, 2020.

Top Ten Tuesday was created by The Broke and the Bookish in June of 2010 and was moved to That Artsy Reader Girl in January of 2018. It was born of a love of lists, a love of books, and a desire to bring bookish friends together.

ttt-big2A Bookish Discovery I made in 2019:

Out of Sync Reading and Reviewing

I know this TTT is supposed to be about “Bookish Discoveries I Made In 2019,” meaning “books, authors, blogs, websites, apps, products, etc.,” but if you have some patience with me, I think you’ll see how I’ve spun this for my own purposes. See, ever since I started this blog in 2013, I’ve made up lists of my favorite books, but I reserved these to include only books I’d read that had been released in that same year. However, it recently occurred to me (in late December, to be truthful) that sometimes I’ve read books a year or two after publication, and I just realized that if had I read them during (or before) their publication year, they would have received places of honor on those annual lists. So, my bookish discovery of 2019 is that these books need to be highlighted, even though they didn’t qualify to get onto my top five or top ten books for the year they were published!

So, here are my top ten books that might have been contenders for my favorites of the year, had I read them the year they were published.

(Links in this post are to my reviews of these books!)

Stone Mattress MediumStone Mattress: Nine Wicked Tales” by Margaret Atwood, Short Fiction, published 2014, reviewed 15-Nov-19. I tried to get the ARC for this collection of short stories, but was turned down. The concept, and of course the author, made me decide I still wanted to read it, so when I won a voucher for The Book Depository, this was one of the books I bought. I’m glad I have it on my shelf (and no, you can’t borrow it, so don’t even ask)!


JDV-MCS2016-Clays-02My Counterfeit Self” by Jane Davis, Fiction, published 2016, reviewed 11-May-19. Jane Davis is an indie author I’ve enjoyed for many years now. Her book “Smash All the Windows” got an honorable mention in 2018, which encouraged me to purchase a couple of her books when they were on special at Amazon. Because this one is about a poet, it quickly became my favorite of all her novels (but I have two more to read, so who knows, that might change). If you don’t know her work, I strongly suggest you correct that oversight as soon as possible.


29245653Hag-Seed” by Margaret Atwood, Fiction, published 2016, reviewed 21-Jul-18. Another Atwood book that I tried to get the ARC for, but was refused (funny, I did get the ARC for her dystopian novel “The Heart Goes Last” – go figure what publishers will allow). The idea of a modern version of Shakespeare’s “The Tempest” was what interested me in this novel, mostly because it’s a play I knew nothing about – never read it, nor seen it in production. Now I know more; thanks, Margaret.


13ed2-miniaturist-1The Miniaturist” by Jessie Burton, Fiction, published 2014, reviewed 02-Dec-17. This book received a whole lot of hype back when it was published, and I generally avoid those. But my husband picked it up on one of his trips abroad. I was originally daunted by its length, but when I finally got around to reading it, the opening line grabbed me right away. Now I have to read her other two books, only one of which do I have on my shelf!


0d6e4-shtum2bpaperbackShtum” by Jim Lester, Fiction, published 2016, reviewed 27-May-17. This was a total whim purchase. We chanced upon this book while wandering around the bookshops of London, and picked it up on a “3 for the price of 2” sale, thinking “why not”. I had never heard of the author before, but the idea of a story about a Jewish man dealing with his autistic son and somewhat estranged father, while he watches his marriage break apart sounded intriguing, and it did not disappoint.


95025-a2bplace2bcalled2bwinter2bpatrick2bgaleA Place Called Winter” by Patrick Gale, Fiction, published 2015, reviewed 16-Feb-16. Again, for some reason, no one wants to give me ARCs for any of Gale’s novels, no matter how much I beg or grovel. That’s why we have to buy them ourselves. No matter, we love his writing, and are willing to wait until the more affordable paperback comes out, because… good things are always worth waiting for, as they say (and I just started reading his 2019 novel).


Love Song Queenie 1The Love Song of Miss Queenie Hennessy” by Rachel Joyce, Fiction, published 2014, reviewed 14-Feb-15. I fell in love with Rachel Joyce’s writing when she published her debut novel “The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry” and her subsequent novel “Perfect” cemented that feeling completely. When I saw she had a type of sequel to Harold Fry, I made sure to buy it as soon as it came out in paperback. There’s no question in my mind that if I had purchased and read it earlier, it would have made my favorites list of 2014.


Almost Famous WomenAlmost Famous Women: Stories” by Megan Mayhew Bergman, Short Fiction, published 2015, reviewed 25-Dec-14. This was one of those books that I took a chance on to get the ARC, and read it well before it was published. I’m including it here because I forgot all about it when I came to doing my favorites of 2015. Mind you, that was the year I read a veritable tsunami of five-star novels, and I was still trying to limit myself to the top five, so I left off all the short story collections that year. Shame, since it really was a wonderful read.


Now, it might not be fair to add these next books, because I wasn’t blogging when these books were published, but still, I could have at least mentioned them when I did my first “best of” list, or I could have done a “best of” list for years prior to my blog’s start date. As they say, hindsight is 20/20, and I’m going to rectify this oversight once and for all (and hey, it is a top TEN list, not a top EIGHT list)!

These are the only two books I’ve read that were published in 2012 to which I gave five-star ratings.

beginners goodbyeThe Beginner’s Goodbye” by Anne Tyler, Fiction, published 2012, reviewed 20-Oct-13. Tyler is one of my favorite authors, but there was a long period of time when I forgot about her, and didn’t seek out her novels. This book was a kind of re-introduction for me, and I’m glad I found her again, since her writing is well worth it. I love her quirky characters, and her dry, but witty writing style which never tries to be flowery or poetic. It seems her publishers appreciate my reviews because I got approval for two ARCs of her novels in recent years, and I just got the ARC for her 2020 book!


9543c-a-perfectly-good-man-hb_largeA Perfectly Good Man” by Patrick Gale, Fiction, published 2012, reviewed 14-Apr-14. This book came out before I even started blogging let alone getting ARCs. My husband picked this one up when he found this in paperback on one of our trips abroad – yes, we’re both big fans of Gale! I believe the reason it took me so long to write a review is because my husband wouldn’t let me read it until he’d finished with it, and he’s always reading bunches of books at the same time, which slows down not only his completing a book, but also my getting my hands on these books, and of course, I’m a slow reader as it is! (Now if only NetGalley or Edelweiss would let me have ARCs of Gale’s novels…)

Bonus Book:

There was only ONE book published in 2011 that I read and thought worthy of a full five stars.

91804-the_cats_table_ondaatje-1The Cat’s Table” by Michael Ondaatje, Fiction, published 2011, reviewed 26-Oct-13. My regular readers already know that Ondaatje is one of my favorites, if not my #1, favorite author. I was so excited about this novel that I purchased it almost the minute it was published (in hardcover, no less), and read it as soon as it was in my hot little hands. I see that I wrote a review of this novel that same year (which I published on a few content sites), and I still think that only “The English Patient” outshines this novel, but only by the minutest of whispers.


35 thoughts on “TCL’s Top Ten Tuesday for January 14, 2020.

  1. OMG, didn’t realize there was another book by Joyce!! I so loved these 2 also.
    One day, I really need to read the last one.
    I tried The Miniaturist in audio and had to DNF it. Looks like I should try again in print.
    Interestingly, when I do my favorites of the year, I consider all the books of read, whatever their publication year. I was curious, so I just checked my, and actually lots of them were published in 2019

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Not only that, but she’s got a new book coming out this year! I’ve pre-ordered a print copy, but I am also trying to get the ARC because… Rachel Joyce! (We were in contact via Instagram, and she told me to write to her publisher. Fingers crossed!)


  2. Loved the twist you gave to this week’s TTT. Maybe because I rarely read in sync meaning my top lists are always the year read, not the year published.

    But you have a lot of good titles in there that made me curious. Thank you for sharing, and for stopping by at The Book Wielding Harpie.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I also received the ARC for The Heart Goes Last by Atwood, and I did not enjoy it at all. I did like The Handmaid’s Tale, but I’ve been scared to try anything else by her. But I do remember being tempted by Hag-seed. Great post!

    Liked by 1 person

      1. I did enjoy the humor, but I just remember not being invested in the story. Maybe someday I’ll give Hag-Seed a try!

        Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m reading Gale’s “Take Nothing With You” now and… WOW, that man can write! Also, I just pre-ordered the new Rachel Joyce – coming out in July, I believe! I’ll try to get the ARC but I haven’t any illusions that they’ll give it to me.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I have similar concerns about “The Miniaturist” (overly hyped). Good to hear, you enjoyed it. Your post also reminds me, I still haven’t read “The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry” which I really want to. Someone said there are similarities to “A Man Called Ove”. Did you think so?

    Liked by 1 person

  5. These books are all new to me (although I know who Margaret Atwood is, of course). 2019 was the first year I published both a list of “Favorite books I read for the first time in 2018” and “Favorite 2018 Releases”. I think if you read enough books in a year, both are appropriate. Especially when you get ARCs. Enchantée wasn’t even eligible for my “Favorite books I read in 2019” list even though it was a 2019 release.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. See… that’s just it. I don’t read that many books in a year, because my mild dyslexia slows me down. As it is, up until now I’ve only been able to do a top five list for each year. This was the first year I got to a top ten list!


  6. I haven’t read any of these, but I also used to love Atwood and Tyler and should probably pick them up again. These might be good ones to start with. I’ve also never read any Patrick Gale, so now I have another author to look for. I read over 50% backlist books, so I do include books from all eras in my “best of” lists, and I’m glad you went back and gave these books your appreciation!

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Great post! I love how you made the prompt your own 🙂 I totally forgot about the Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry but I do remember stumbling upon it at random at a hostel while traveling and devouring it. It was so great 🙂 I had no idea there was a sequel out but I’m going to have to check it out!

    My <a href=”“>TTT post

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Great list! I remember seeing Almost Famous Women around a couple of years ago – I love the cover! – and it’s one I’d like to try. I’ve only read The Penelopiad by Margaret Atwood, so I really need to read some more of her work this year!

    Liked by 1 person

  9. I love that you still gave these books their moment to shine even though they didn’t qualify for your favorites list. I really need to read something by Margaret Atwood this year!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Davida Chazan Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.