More Daring than Darling.

Book Review for “Lady Clementine” by Marie Benedict.

Lady Clementine small.pngThis is the story of Clementine Churchill, the woman married to Winston Churchill, best known as the man who was twice Prime Minister of the United Kingdom. Although most people know of Winston’s exploits, which included successes and failures alike, the woman at his side set a new standard for a PM’s wife, but her influence over her husband, and thereby the governing of the country, was at turns overlooked, derided, and marginalized. With this biographical, women’s, historical fiction novel, Benedict attempts to right this wrong, and place her on almost equal footing with the very famous man she was married to for over 56 years, so that we can finally appreciate who she was, and what she did for her country – both officially and unofficially.

First off, I must admit that found the title of this novel to be a bit confusing. If you look her up on Wikipedia, you’ll see a very skeletal biography. But what you will find is that she obtained titles in her own right. She became a Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE) in 1918, a Dame Grand Cross in 1946, and only received the title of Lady in 1953 by virtue of Winston’s knighthood. Finally, she actually became a life peer in her own right when she was awarded the title of Baroness in 1965, a few months after Winston’s death. Therefore, the particular title of “Lady” was one of the few she received only because she was married to Winston. Considering everything she accomplished, to portray her with this title, seems terribly ironic, if you ask me. But… what’s in a name, right? (That said, to be totally honest, I’m also not wholly in love with the cover art, but that shouldn’t put you off this novel. I mean, it isn’t horrible, but it also isn’t extraordinary.)

With that out of the way, I found that Benedict uses her straightforward and uncompromising literary style to focus this novel mostly on Clementine’s life starting from when she met Winston in 1904, through 1945. That means the book encompasses both world wars. Think about it… to put 41 (very eventful) years into just under 340 pages is no small accomplishment. To achieve this, Benedict did some very careful picking and choosing, so that the events that got into the book were almost only those where Clementine’s involvement was either obvious, or should have been much more discernable. For example, Benedict describes the open secret that Clementine helped Winston write most of his speeches and had a large hand in editing his writings. Benedict also shows Clementine meeting with international heads of state, even in situations where she was the only spouse in the room. There’s also the relationship with Eleanor Roosevelt, the famously heavy-handed and highly influential wife of Franklin D. Roosevelt, who was the US President during almost all of WWII. The parallels Benedict drew between these two women was probably my favorite part of this novel, since they were truly the proverbial “two peas in a pod”! Think about it – FDR had his debilitating Polio (albeit before he became president), and Winston almost died of pneumonia while he was PM during WWII. These wives nursed their husbands, knowing full well that their husbands’ political careers would take front and center the moment they were once again physically able.

I think what impressed me the most about this novel was how Benedict succeeded in making all of it – even the places where Clementine wasn’t playing an instrumental part – truly Clementine’s story, told in first person. That doesn’t mean that she ignored Winston here, but rather that we saw it all through Clementine’s eyes, through her emotions, through her feelings, and through her own actions (or inaction, as sometimes the case might have been). Benedict also suggests that Clementine was very self-aware regarding her own inadequacies and ineffectiveness, and in fact more than implies that Clementine suffered from no small amount of emotional distress that might have had an impact on her mental health. I don’t know if this is factually correct, since my copy of the ARC didn’t have any author’s notes included, but it certainly sounded plausible to me.

What I’m saying here is that essentially, with the tiny exception to the title of this novel (which I suspect may not have been Benedict’s first choice), this is precisely the type of novel that I look for in women’s, biographical, historical fiction. Benedict’s precise, practically surgical selection of events shows Clementine as not just a strong supporter of her husband, but a tough, intelligent, leader of a woman in her own right, and one who doesn’t hesitate to take action, even when its controversial, or when failure is lurking in the shadows. Clementine isn’t simply a bystander or witness, because she’s practically on the front lines of every battle, even when she’s behind the scenes pulling her own strings. It seems very strange for me to say this of the first book of 2020, but I must give this novel a full five out of five stars. Benedict has outdone herself here, and I cannot recommend this book warmly enough.

00472-5starstiny

fc16c-netgalleytinySourcebooks Landmark released “Lady Clementine” by Marie Benedict on January 7, 2020. This book is available (via the following affiliate links) from Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Walmart (Kobo) US eBooks and audiobooks, the website eBooks.com, iTunes (iBook or audiobook), Wordery or The Book Depository (both with free worldwide delivery), new or used from Alibris, used from Better World Books (promoting libraries and world literary), as well as from an IndieBound store near you. I would like to thank the publishers for sending me an ARC of this novel via NetGalley.

20 thoughts on “More Daring than Darling.

  1. Good review. I had a hard time with it and quit. It wasn’t bad–just a problem I have sometimes with Historical Fiction that it isn’t “MY” Clemintine–I’ve read everything put out since the 70s on her. She is fascinating. Like the FD Roosevelts, her kids were disasters except for Mary. Fascinating family, career, marriage, friendships.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Sounds really good and what a great review. She is a fascinating person and you have made the book sound really appealing. Like you, I enjoy fiction based on real characters. (Also being pedantic but Churchill was Prime Minister of the UK, not just England. 😊)

    Liked by 1 person

  3. As I read your amazing review I’m struggling to finish up my own! For me, her amazing accomplishments are tarnished by her emotional abandonment of her five children. I find it difficult to completely admire her because of it. However, she’s certainly an interesting, fascinating, and brilliant person!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This is what I think makes the story so good – precisely because Benedict doesn’t hold back on that side of her, and we see those flaws in full light. She didn’t succeed in juggling motherhood with her ambitions, but she tried, and admitted her failure. Glossing over that would have been wrong, if you ask me.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Just to be pedantic 🙂 – the wife of a knight or baronet is Lady Surname, not Lady First Name, so she was Lady Churchill, not Lady Clementine, as Sir Winston Churchill’s wife. As a life peer, she was Baroness Churchill (or Baroness Spencer-Churchill) – or, if she wanted to use her first name, Clementine, Baroness Churchill. So “Lady Clementine” is just plain wrong! You’re only Lady First Name if you’re the daughter of a duke or earl or marquess, like Lady Louise Mountbatten-Windsor, or Lady Diana Spencer before her marriage. Sorry for the essay, but it annoys me when authors make mistakes like that when they’re supposed to have done their research!! The book sounds interesting, though.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You’re right, even though she was legally the daughter of Sir Henry Hozier and Lady Blanche Hozier (a daughter of David Ogilvy, 10th Earl of Airlie), and there were rumors that her real father was actually a Duke (her mother was famous for her many lovers). But I think the reason she used “Lady Clementine” is because of a scene where American soldiers sang the famous folk song “My Darling Clementine” to her, and changed the word darling to lady.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to WordsAndPeace Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.