The Best of the Best Top 5 List for 2013-2019

You’ve seen my yearly Top Five lists, but how about a “best of the best” list?

For those of you who have been following this blog, you’ll know that I’ve been producing a list of my favorite books published for each of the years I’ve been blogging. While I probably should have done this after my 2017 list, so I’d have the top five of the last five years, but I didn’t think of it back then, so I’m going to give you instead my top seven of the last seven years. In any case, I’m hoping this will become a new yearly feature, that is unless you all get sick and tired of it (let me know, okay)!

Anyway, here were the #1 ranked books of the past years:

Wait a minute – that’s 11 books over seven years. Well, that means that first I’m going to have to cut down the ones that tied in 2015 and 2017. But… rather than discard them altogether, they surely deserve to be included as honorable mentions. So let’s start there:

The first three honorable mentions were relatively easy to choose. In descending order, they go to:

#4 – The novella, “The Deal of a Lifetime” by Fredrik Backman (partially because it isn’t a full-length novel, and well, there’s some magical realism in there that isn’t totally my thing, even though I ignored that in the rating).

#3 – Backman’s “Beartown” and,

#2 – “My Grandmother Sends Her Regards and Apologises,” also by Backman.

This isn’t to say that I didn’t love these three books or Backman’s writing, but if I have to compare them with the others, then to be perfectly honest, they’re just that tiny touch of a minuscule bit of a level slightly lower than the rest (by a whisker!).

That leaves my #1 favorite honorable mention, and the book that came devilishly close to getting a spot on this list as “The Music Shop” by Rachel Joyce. I probably should have let it tie it for 7th place, but I really wanted just one book from each year, so I’m letting it take the top honorable mention spot instead.


That leaves me with the following, which again, was no easy task to rank. And the winners are:


You might be wondering how it is that my favorite author (Michael Ondaatje) didn’t take the top of the top of this list? Well, to begin with, the sheer beauty of the writing in the Rabinyan book was what pushed that one up the list. The Lawhon novel was the most engrossing historical fiction novel I’ve ever read (and yes, I was really ticked off that this didn’t bring Lawhon more recognition for her amazing writing). Bototis moved up not only for the beautiful writing, but also for the originality and the fact that it was a debut novel. As for the Ozeki, beyond a doubt, that is a book that has kept me thinking about it more than any other on this list, ever since my first reading. Furthermore, while I loved Warlight, it isn’t my absolute favorite of his books (that’s still reserved for “The English Patient” with “The Cat’s Table” an extremely close second). I also know that I almost couldn’t write the review of Ozeki’s book, because I loved it so much.

You also might wonder how an obscure Israeli author’s novel overtook what I think is Tyler’s finest work to date, not to mention pushing down the debut novel that skyrocketed Fredrik Backman to international acclaim. The answer to that is simple – Rabinyan’s book is the finest re-imagining and modernization of Shakespeare’s “Romeo & Juliet” that I’ve ever read. Agree or disagree with these decisions as you will! (I know you will. Or will you? Hell, I’ve changed my mind on this list at least 20 times already, so go right ahead.)

There you have it, my best of the best for the years 2013-2019.

Who knows, but maybe my #1 book for 2020 will beat them all out and grab the top spot from Ozeki this year!

New Top Five List Announced


16 thoughts on “The Best of the Best Top 5 List for 2013-2019

  1. I’ve never really tried to rank books against each other. Even my “best books I read this year” lists stand alphabetically by author’s last name. I have compiled a list of the best 5 books I’ve ever read, but even that one is unranked. Usually I like individual books for very different reasons–reasons so different that comparing the books becomes an impossible “apples and oranges” situation. (I don’t think I’m making much sense here. There’s probably a good Blog Discussion Challenge post that should come out of all this!)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I hear you, and I appreciate how you don’t want to compare apples to oranges. My ranking is more a combination of enjoyment and staying power. By the latter, I mean if a book sticks with me and I can remember scenes from it months or years afterwards.


  2. There are several books on here that I plan to add to my TBR. I have read all the Backman books as he is one of my favourite authors. It must be so hard to narrow it down like you did. It was interesting to see your process.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I love hearing you wrestle with this list out loud! And, if you’re like me, The list might be different on another day! So very difficult to compare and rank such different and lovely books! I loved The Music Shop…especially the ending! Glad to see it topped the honorable mention! Great list! 🙌😍

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.